Latest blog articles
India's GST will come on time, but multiple rates will dilute benefits
By Douglas Busvine and Manoj Kumar
NEW DELHI (Reuters) - India moved a step closer to creating a national sales tax but a deal on rates reached on Thursday will hit some businesses harder than others, while its complexity will dilute any boost to growth and undermine its reliability as a revenue generator.
The Goods and Services Tax (GST), due to be rolled out from April 1, 2017, had been billed as the one reform that could help Prime Minister Narendra Modi deliver on his jobs and growth agenda. In a key Modi win, parliament amended the constitution in August to clear the way for the GST, which would unify Asia's third-largest economy into a common market for the first time.
But Thursday's bargain between Finance Minister Arun Jaitley and his counterparts from India's 27 state governments has exposed the difficulties of dealing with so many stakeholders.
The GST Council, set up to oversee the tax, agreed on a more steeply progressive structure for goods than earlier foreseen with rates of 5, 12, 18 and 28 percent, depending on the kind of product involved. The top rate, Jaitley said, would apply to the kind of goods bought by middle-class Indians.
On top of that, essentials like grains that make up half the consumer price index would not be taxed at all. Finally, a "cess" - a separate central tax - would be added to the top 28 percent GST rate on luxury cars and harmful products like tobacco and fizzy drinks.
The total burden of this "sin" tax still has to be worked out, as does the rate applying to services that are now taxed at a rate of 15 percent.
"India is like the European Union with a central government," said Harishanker Subramanian, head of indirect tax at EY. "This is fiscal federalism. It's not easy."
Despite the loose ends, it now looks increasingly likely that parliament, which opens its winter session on Nov. 16, will be able to pass key GST laws, as state assemblies must also do, to keep the launch timeline on track.
The GST should be a positive development for Jay Kannaiyan, who runs a startup that makes and sells low-cost air purifiers, a product in big demand because of an air pollution crisis in the capital New Delhi and other Indian cities.
Kannaiyan backs the GST because it would free his firm, Smart Air Filters Pvt Ltd, from the red tape arising from value-added tax (VAT) that is currently collected by the states and is one of several levies due to be abolished under the tax reform.
VAT rules vary widely, and the tax can be levied at different times during the transfer of goods, depending on the state.
"It is a hassle as it slows down our operations," Kannaiyan, 35, said at his tiny workspace in a dusty commercial district on Delhi's southern fringes.
His greatest worry is the possibility that consumer durables will be taxed at the top 28 percent GST rate, not the 18 percent earlier foreseen, hurting his margins. Which product is assigned to which rate still has to be worked out.
The uncertainty "hurts us, it hurts our planning," said Kannaiyan, who plans to more than double sales in the next year.
RELABELED, NOT REFORMED
It's a far cry from the attributes of a so-called "good tax" - that is low, flat and broad. And advocates of a simpler GST have gone on the offensive, denouncing the current proposal as a mere relabeling; not a genuine reform.
Officials and experts involved in the policy process say Jaitley took the path of least resistance by pitching tax rates broadly in line with the existing burden to avoid any unwelcome spike in inflation when the GST comes into force.
"The approach outlined by the authorities signals a disappointing beginning which well could have been otherwise," said Vijay Kelkar, a former finance secretary who penned a landmark 2009 report on the GST.
Jaitley argues that multiple GST rates are needed to prevent the tax falling too hard on the poor. "Air conditioners and hawai chappals cannot be taxed at the same rate," he wrote in a recent blog post, using the Hindi name for flip flops.
GROWTH BOOST DILUTED
Business groups, tax experts and economists say the GST, if passed in this form, would generate less of a lift to economic growth and state revenues than a simpler tax.
"An ideal GST would have carried one single rate with very few exemptions - instead what we've got is a multiple tax rate structure and multiple exemptions," said Pranjul Bhandari, chief India economist at HSBC, who has halved her forecast of the GST's growth boost to 0.4 of a percentage point.
Where accountants do find fault is with the proposed cess that would raise funds for Jaitley to offset initial revenue losses to states arising from the GST.
"The concept of a cess is a distortion," said Sachin Menon, head of indirect tax at KPMG India. "The very purpose of the GST is to remove multiple taxes and to have a uniform law and uniform taxes across the country."
(Writing by Douglas Busvine; Edited by Martin Howell)
Legal framework needed to develop adventure travel
Vietnam is home to many natural features appropriate for adventure travel activities such as hiking, mountain climbing, car and motorbike off-road driving, canoeing and kayaking, surfing, parachuting and paragliding. Kayaking in Ha Long Bay But in addition to the above-mentioned advantages, adventure travel in Vietnam still lacks professionalism and experience, resulting in safety risks for tourists.A number of travel agencies have been organising adventure tours at their own discretion… chat_bubble_outline Read More...
VN macadamia growers advised to be cautious
The planting of Macadamia trees is expected to help the Central Highlands provinces in general and Dak Lak province in particular to reduce poverty.However, experts say further studies on land, climate, seedlings and cultivation techniques should be carried out before the tree is put into large-scale cultivation in the region.Macadamia trees made first appearance in Vietnam in the 1990s, but farmers in the Central Highlands only started cultivating them in 2000.Now they have around 2,300 ha of… chat_bubble_outline Read More...
Vietnam strives to provide primary health care to all people
Because the grassroots medical systems are unable to meet people’s treatment demand, the Prime Minister has approved the project to improve the system’s quality in districts in an effort to provide primary health care to all people. The project which will be carried out from 2016 to 2025 aims to re-structure operating mechanism, financing mechanism, personnel growth to improve service quality of district medical clinics to ensure provision of primary health care service, examination and… chat_bubble_outline Read More...
Ties unscathed by Queen Elizabeth's "rude" comment, China paper says
Ties between China and Britain will not be harmed by Queen Elizabeth being caught on camera saying Chinese officials were "very rude", said an influential Chinese newspaper on Thursday which instead laid the blame on Western media "barbarians". In footage broadcast by the BBC of a garden party at Buckingham Palace on Tuesday, Queen Elizabeth was heard to commiserate with a senior police officer who had the "bad luck" to be in charge of security during Chinese President Xi Jinping's state visit… chat_bubble_outline Read More...
Premier League: Ranieri turns back the clock to make Leicester champions
Read on the original site chat_bubble_outline Read More...